Charmed, Season 4

Piper:
How, how, how could you do that? How could you just let him go?

Phoebe:
I don't know why you're so upset, we saved the innocent, didn't we?

Piper:
I can't talk to her. You talk to her!

Leo:
Phoebe...

Phoebe:
Things are not as black and white as they used to be, ok? I can't just go around and kill demons anymore.

Paige:
Why not? We heard you just killed two last night.

Phoebe:
Yeah, well that was different, he was getting on my nerves. I promised Cole I wouldn't kill anymore. And killing Malick would have been a huge betrayal.

Piper:
Malick? You're on a first-name basis with the demons?

Leo:
If you were just gonna order him to stop, you could have done that on your own. Why did you even come to us?

Phoebe:
Because I missed you guys! Okay? Is that so wrong? I missed you!

Leo:
Phoebe, you can't be the Queen of the Underworld and a Charmed One. You can't have it both ways.

Phoebe:
Why not? Just because it's different doesn't mean that it can't work. And you all miss me too, even though I'm sure Piper probably doesn't want to admit it to herself.

Paige:
Of course, we miss you, honey.

Phoebe:
Well, you can have me back. You can have the Power of Three back. You just have to be willing to meet me halfway.

Piper:
Phoebe, you can't protect the innocent and save demons. It just doesn't work that way.

Phoebe:
Apparently, it does. He's alive, isn't he?

Paige:
Yeah, but your friend Malick is gonna come back.

Phoebe:
You don't know that.

Piper:
That's what they do, Phoebe. They come back. They snarl, and come back.

Paige:
Yeah, and now we have to worry about protecting him instead of trying to save you.

Phoebe:
You think I need saving?

Piper:
Are you kidding me? That baby inside you has corrupted you, more than you think.

Phoebe:
Piper...

Piper:
Don't Piper me. This is insane. What are you saying is insane. You can not come back. You can not work with us, as long as you're married to the Source.

Phoebe:
So what do you want me to do?! You want me to leave my husband?!

Piper:
Yes!

Phoebe:
That is not fair!

Leo:
It's not fair Phoebe, but you have to pick a side. Good or evil. That's how it works. Even though it means giving up someone you love, you have to choose.

Phoebe:
I'm really sorry you feel that way. (she disappeares in the flame) .

Piper:
I can't do this. (walks away)

Paige:
What about Greg?

(Piper unfreezes him.)

Greg:
Oh no, not again.