NCIS, Season 4

Contractor:
Reminds me of that urban legend.

Gibbs:
Which one is that?

Contractor:
Guy dresses up like Santa, you know, for Christmas Eve to surprise his girlfriend but he never shows. She's convinced that the bastard dumped her, badmouths him all over town.

Ducky:
Until they find the poor soul's body months later, still clutching the little box with her shiny new engagement ring. And the moral of course is...

Gibbs:
Never a good idea to get married.

Ducky:
No, it's best not to judge someone until all the facts are in.

Gibbs:
I like mine better.