Your Pretty Face Is Going to Hell2013

[Gary gets crushed by a big wall, after giving apologies to Benji]

Satan:
NOOOOOO! GARY! Ga-- No! NO! When somebody comes to hell, you think they're gonna be forever. [sobs]

[cuts to the next scene in Satan's office shows everything that happened from the beginning of the episode was actually a scripted episode they made by Satan and the other demons they've been acting this entire time while watching from Satan's TV]

Satan:
You see this? Never be afraid to show your emotions, even if they're fake. You taught me that.

Benji:
That's how you win a pair of these! Best Short-form Supernatural Reality Show Unscripted, baby!

Gary Bunda:
I don't really understand how I don't win an Emmy for my own damn show.

Benji:
If these walls could talk? Right, Satan? Or more like if this shelf could shut up. Am I right? [laughing]

[cuts to next scene where Gary is turned into a shelf after getting crushed from a big wall]

Gary Bunda:
I'm a man, not a shelf.