Brooklyn Nine-Nine, Season 5

[Jake and a witness are viewing a line-up]

Jake:
So, do you recognize any of these men?

Witness:
I was hiding in the bathroom stall, so I didn't see his face. But I heard him. He was singing along to the music at the bar.

Jake:
Do you remember what he was singing?

Witness:
I think it was that song, "I Want It That Way".

Jake:
Backstreet Boys. I'm familiar. Okay. [presses intercom] Number one, could you please sing the opening to "I Want It That Way"?

Number One:
Really? Okay. [singing] You are my fire...

Jake:
Number two, keep it going.

Number Two:
The one desire...

Jake:
Number three.

Number Three:
Believe when I say...

Jake:
Number four.

Number Four:
I want it that way.

Jake:
[singing] Tell me why!

Suspects:
Ain't nothing but a heartache...

Jake:
Tell me why!

Suspects:
Ain't nothing but a mistake...

Jake:
[still singing] Now number five...

Number Five:
I never want to hear you say...

Suspects:
I want it that way.

Jake:
Ah, chills! Literal chills!

Witness:
It was number five. Number five killed my brother.

Jake:
Oh my God, I forgot about that part.