[Chuck is sitting in the living room when Jimmy and Kim come by to pick up the Mesa Verde files]
Jimmy:
So Chuck, what's the deal with the locks?
Chuck:
Kim, I was hoping to have this conversation with you and you alone. However, I guess it's time to clear the air once and for all.
Kim:
Clear the air about what?
Chuck:
[looks at Jimmy] He sabotaged me.
Jimmy:
[feigning ignorance] Why, what are you—
Chuck:
Please. Don't bother. You and I both know exactly what I'm talking about.
Jimmy:
I don't.
Chuck:
Yesterday morning was the worst professional humiliation of my life. A single transpositional error cost my client time and money, and permanently damaged my reputation. Then I realized, it wasn't an error. Not at all. A week ago last night, I was right there on that couch, barely conscious. And Jimmy showed up... [stands up from his chair] ...and he sent Ernesto away. My brother was going to take care of me. And in the dead of night, he went through my Mesa Verde files.
Jimmy:
All right, you know what? We don't have to listen to this—
Chuck:
She does! [to Kim] You do, for your own good. [taps his hand on the Mesa Verde file boxes] And in these files are thirteen documents containing the address of Mesa Verde's proposed branch: 1261 Rosella Drive, Scottsdale, Arizona. Jimmy pulled each and every one. And he left me here, sweating and delirious, while he went off to doctor them. You'd need a photocopier for that. Where'd you go, some all-night copy shop? [Jimmy scoffs] With a little careful cutting and pasting he created duplicates, virtually identical to my originals but with one key change: 1261 Rosella Drive became 1216 Rosella Drive.
Jimmy:
This is sounding like a lot of work.
Chuck:
No one ever accused you of being lazy. Every other sin in the book, but not that one. [to Kim] And if you're wondering if Jimmy's up to a little casual forgery, you should know in high school, he had a thriving business making fake IDs so his buddies could buy beer.
Jimmy:
You're gonna go all the way back to high school, huh?
Chuck:
Hey, you and Mozart, huh? You both started young. He came back here and put his new versions in my files. And then, the next day, my caring brother took his leave. He knew that I would use his modified documents to write Mesa Verde's submission to the state regulator. And so I did, over and over. I typed "1216" instead of "1261". I remember thinking, "1216 Rosella Drive. That's just one year after 1215, the year the Magna Carta was signed."
Jimmy:
Jesus, Chuck, you are unbelievable. So you're saying, if we look in here, all the addresses will be wrong?
Chuck:
Well of course you weren't gonna leave evidence behind. I'm guessing yesterday morning you waited until I left, then used your key to let yourself in and returned the originals. No crime is complete without the cover-up.
Jimmy:
Oh, come on! I did this, what, for some business?
Chuck:
[to Kim] He did it for you. [long pause] Oh, I'm sure you didn't know anything about it. I believe he went off on his own and did this as some kind of twisted romantic gesture.
Jimmy:
Chuck, I think you need to lie down with a cold washcloth on your head.
Chuck:
[to Kim; continued] And now that you know, you have no choice. This is about a client. A client who has been defrauded. As a sworn officer of the court, as Mesa Verde's attorney of record, you have no recourse but to go to Kevin Wachtell and make a full disclosure.
Jimmy:
This—this whole song and dance is all about getting his client back. That's all this is.
Chuck:
Not in the least. If knowing the truth, they still go with you—
Jimmy:
You can't stand the fact that they chose her over you.
Chuck:
[exasperated] I can't stand the fact that my own brother stabbed me in the back! I can't stand the fact that you've deceived and ruined this fine young woman!
Jimmy:
Ruined?! What is this, the 1840s? What are you talking about? She's not ruined!
Kim:
Jimmy. [beat; Chuck and Jimmy look at Kim] If what you're saying is true, Jimmy could be charged with forgery. Fraud. Falsifying evidence. Even breaking and entering.
Chuck:
Frankly, I am sick about this. But facts are facts.
Kim:
...And what is your evidence?
Chuck:
My evidence? My evidence is knowing my brother for his entire life.
Kim:
Chuck, I think there is another explanation. It's a simpler one: you made a mistake.
Chuck:
I did not.
Kim:
You're working by lantern light, squinting over ten-point type for hour after hour. Mistakenly changing "1261" to "1216" would be the most natural thing in the world. It could certainly happen to me.
Chuck:
I did not make a mistake!
Kim:
I believe you did.
Chuck:
Look, I understand that you have great affection for Jimmy! A great many people do! But please open your eyes here!
Kim:
You made a mistake. And instead of just facing up to it, you accuse your brother of plotting against you. You come up with this elaborate scheme–
Chuck:
He's capable of this! You know he is!
Kim:
I know he's not perfect. And I know he cuts corners. But you're the one who made him this way. He idolizes you, he accepts you, he takes care of you, and all he ever wanted was your love and support. But all you've ever done is judge him. You never believed in him, you never wanted him to succeed. [beat] And you know what? I feel sorry for him. [beat] And I feel sorry for you.
Share your thoughts on Better Call Saul, Season 2's quotes with the community:
Report Comment
We're doing our best to make sure our content is useful, accurate and safe.
If by any chance you spot an inappropriate comment while navigating through our website please use this form to let us know, and we'll take care of it shortly.
Attachment
You need to be logged in to favorite.
Log In